The Minnesota Debt Collection Lawsuit Guide: Part 3—After the Answer

This is part three of a three-part series about debt collection lawsuits in Minnesota:

Part 1—The Summons & Complaint
Part 2—The Answer

Now that you’ve served your answer to the collection lawsuit, you’re probably wondering what happens next. After all, the answer is only the beginning of the contested part of the case.

Here’s an overview of the remaining steps of the process.

Step 1 -- Initial Disclosures and Discovery Plan

After the answer is served, the parties are required to confer about the case and develop a plan for discovery (Step 2, below). This conference, which can be by phone, is required to take place within 30 days of the original due date for the Answer. Most debt collection law firms will send a letter to set up the conference.

The parties are also required  to disclose all known witnesses and supporting documents, as well as to itemize the claimed damages and describe any insurance coverage for the claims, at this stage of the case. These are known as Rule 26 initial disclosures and must be sent to the other side within 60 days of the original due date for the Answer.

Step 2 -- Discovery

Once the discovery conference takes place , the next step in a debt collection lawsuit is discovery. If the case has not been filed with the court, there is no explicit time frame for discovery to happen and the parties are free to serve discovery whenever they wish. Once the case is filed with the court, the court will issue a deadline for discovery to be completed by.

Discovery is simply an opportunity for the parties to exchange information about the claims and defenses involved in a case. Discovery is not compulsory and a party is only required to provide information if they're properly asked. The most common forms of discovery in a debt collection case are Interrogatories, Request for Production of Documents, and Requests for Admission. Interrogatories are basically just questions that one party asks of the other. Requests for Production of Documents, as the name implies, requires that certain documents related to the case be produced. And Requests for Admission are essentially true or false questions about the claims or defenses in the case.

To request discovery, a party has to properly serve their Interrogatories, Requests for Production of Documents, or Requests for Admission. Written discovery is usually served by mailing the requests to the other side. The other party then has 30 days from the day the discovery was served to respond fully. Simply mailing a letter to the other side asking them to provide information about the case is not sufficient and doesn't trigger the other side's duty to respond.

Requests for Admission are probably the most critical part of discovery, because if they are not responded to within 30 days, they are considered admitted. Creditors write their Requests for Admission carefully so that if the consumer doesn't respond to them, they will end up admitting each element of the creditor's claims. I've seen cases where the only evidence that the creditor put in front of the judge was the consumer's failure to respond to the Requests for Admission.

Step 3 -- Filing the Case With the Court

In 2013, the court rules were changed to require that cases be filed with the court and brought under court supervision within one year from the date the Complaint was served. If the case isn't filed within the one-year time limit, it is automatically dismissed with prejudice and can't be re-started. The rules allow the parties to agree to extend this deadline, but there rarely is a reason for a defendant in a debt collection lawsuit to agree to extend this deadline.

To file the case, each party must file their initial pleading (ie. the Complaint or the Answer) and pay the court filing fee, which is about $300. The parties also have to file their discovery plan from Step 1 above. Once the case is filed, it will typically be assigned to a judge and the court will issue a schedule with deadlines for the case.

Step 4 -- Summary Judgment Motion

The next step in the majority of debt collection lawsuits is the creditor's summary judgment motion. This is a hearing in front of a judge where the creditor will offer all of its evidence and legal arguments and ask the judge to give them a judgment. Defending a summary judgment motion is a complicated process, but essentially it requires the consumer to file a brief with his legal arguments, any written testimony that he wishes the court to consider, and any documents that he wants the court to review. There is a hearing where the judge will ask questions of both sides. The judge then considers all of the arguments and evidence and decides whether the creditor is entitled to a judgment. If the judge rules in favor of the creditor, a judgment is entered and the case is over. If the judge rules against the creditor, then the case will proceed to trial.

Step 5 -- Mediation

In most cases, the court requires the parties to engage in mediation. Mediation involves a neutral third-party, sometimes a retired judge, that tries to help the parties resolve their differences and settle the case. The parties usually have to bear the cost of hiring a mediator, although more and more courts are offering low-cost mediation for qualifying cases and parties. The mediator can't require you to settle the case, but they can help you see the benefits of settlement and propose different settlement options.

Step 6 -- Pre-Trial and Trial

If you're fortunate enough to defeat the creditor's summary judgment motion and the parties don't settle at mediation, the next step in a debt collection lawsuit will be a trial. The judge will issue detailed instructions about the time leading up to trial. There are so many variables at this point that it's difficult to describe all the potential scenarios. If you get to this point, you would benefit greatly from discussing your case with an attorney. You have a great deal of leverage to get the case resolved if you defeat the summary judgment motion and an experienced consumer attorney can help you maximize that leverage to get the best possible outcome.

A Final Word -- the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act

The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act is a federal law that regulates what debt collectors can and can't do when collecting debts. The FDCPA applies even if you owe the debt. If you're involved in a debt collection lawsuit, you should to educate yourself about the FDCPA.

Basically, a debt collector can't harass you, lie to you, or use any unfair collection tactics. If a debt collector violates the FDCPA, you can sue it for up to $1,000, plus any actual damages. The debt collector also has to pay your attorney fees and costs if you win your FDCPA case. A FDCPA claim can often be brought as a counterclaim in a debt collection lawsuit, which often will give you additional leverage to get the suit resolved.

What’s Next in This Series

This is Part 3 of our Minnesota Debt Collection Lawsuit Guide. We also cover:

Part 1—The Summons & Complaint
Part 2—The Answer

 

Ready to talk to a lawyer about your collection lawsuit?
Schedule a consult with debt defense lawyer Todd Murray.

2017_11_03 Pic.png

Since 2009, Todd has helped hundreds of Minnesotans defend debt collection lawsuits. His work has saved his clients millions of dollars (and many sleepless nights). Todd’s clients have described him as “very professional and easy to work with.” He lives in Minneapolis with his wife and four children.

Learned Your Odometer Was Rolled Back? A Complete Guide for Minnesota Car Buyers

Discovering your car’s odometer was rolled back feels like a punch in the gut. You thought you were buying reliability, instead, you’ve been cheated. You’re not alone: according to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, more than 450,000 vehicles are sold every year with false odometer readings, costing buyers over $1 billion annually.

If you’ve just learned you’re one of these unlucky buyers, here’s everything you need to know about odometer rollbacks in Minnesota and what you can do about it.

What Is an Odometer Rollback?

An odometer rollback happens when the mileage reading on a vehicle is altered to make it look like the car has been driven less than it really has. Modern vehicles use computers to track and display mileage and scammers use “mileage correction” tools to plug into the system and change the numbers.

Indeed, a quick search for “odometer rollback tool” returns a bunch of “mileage correction” devices:

Screen Shot 2020-10-30 at 2.19.45 PM.png

Why Odometer Fraud Matters

Odometer rollbacks aren’t just a technicality. They create real harm:

  • Financial Loss: You overpaid, often by thousands of dollars.

  • Resale Problems: You’ll never be able to trade the vehicle in. Dealers and private buyers check Carfax, and once an odometer discrepancy is noted, resale value collapses.

  • Safety Risks: Higher-mileage cars have more wear and tear — tires, brakes, suspension, airbags — making them less safe than you thought.

How to Spot an Odometer Rollback

Sometimes you can catch fraud before or after buying. Here’s what to check:

  • Vehicle history report (Carfax, AutoCheck): Look for mileage discrepancies.

  • Maintenance records: Oil changes and service receipts show mileage at the time. Check glove boxes, seats, and door stickers for past records.

  • Title history: Request a full history from the Minnesota DMV. Older titles may reveal inconsistencies.

  • Physical wear: A car with “low mileage” shouldn’t have worn pedals, sagging seats, or faded steering wheels.

  • Mechanic inspection: A trusted mechanic can spot if the car looks far more “used” than the odometer suggests.

Minnesota and Federal Odometer Fraud Laws

Both federal and state law make odometer tampering illegal.

  • Federal Law (49 U.S.C. §32701): Prohibits tampering with odometers and requires truthful mileage disclosures.

  • Minnesota Law (Minn. Stat. §325E.14): Makes odometer fraud a crime and provides remedies for victims.

Penalties include:

  • Civil damages: At least $10,000 or three times your actual damages (whichever is greater).

  • Attorney’s fees and costs: If you win, the dealer must pay your lawyer and court costs.

  • Criminal penalties: Jail time and fines for violators.

What Are My Legal Rights?

If you’ve been a victim of odometer fraud in Minnesota or Western Wisconsin, you can take action:

  • Sue the dealer who sold the vehicle with a false odometer reading.

  • Recover damages: Refunds, compensation for lost value, and additional damages as provided by law.

  • Pay nothing upfront: At Friedman Murray, we handle these cases on contingency, meaning we only get paid if you win.

  • Important Note: We only take cases against licensed dealers. We generally cannot help with private-party transactions. Documentation (Carfax, repair records, title history) is required to build your case.

FAQ: Odometer Rollbacks in Minnesota

How common is odometer fraud in Minnesota? Very. The NHTSA estimates over 450,000 cars are sold with false readings each year. Minnesota, with its heavy used-car market, is no exception.

Can I sue if the dealer didn’t personally roll it back? Yes. The law prohibits sellers from knowingly making false mileage disclosures — even if they weren’t the ones who altered it.

What if I bought from a private seller? While you may have legal claims if the private seller broke the law, our firm only handles cases against licensed dealers.

 

Just learned your vehicle’s odometer was rolled back?
Get a free consult with auto fraud attorney Todd Murray.

2017_11_03 Pic.png

Since 2009, Todd has been helping Minnesotans combat fraudulent auto sales by used car dealers. His work has returned hundreds of thousands of dollars to his clients’ pockets and has improved the legal protections for used car buyers throughout the state. Todd’s clients have described him as “very professional and easy to work with.” He lives in Minneapolis with his wife and four children.

How to respond to a debt collector's requests for admission

A favorite litigation tactic used by collection lawyers in a debt collection lawsuit is to serve an unsuspecting consumer with requests for admission. These are typically a series of statements that you are asked to admit or deny. In other forms of litigation, requests for admission are typically used to figure out what facts are disputed in the case. But debt collectors don't use requests for admission to learn more about what facts you dispute. In fact, they couldn’t care less about your answers and would prefer that you didn't answer them at all.

Why? Because if you don't answer the requests for admission within 30 days, every statement in them is then considered to be true. So debt collectors structure them in a way that if you don't answer, you've admitted each element of their case. And debt collectors are well-aware that the majority of people won’t answer the admissions because they don't understand the serious consequences of not doing so.

This is just another example of debt collectors using a court rule for something other than its intended purpose. I've seen debt collectors ask judges to rule in their favor based only on the consumer's failure to respond to the requests for admission. They didn't produce any billing statements, applications, terms and conditions—any evidence. And though I suspect that most judges know exactly what the debt collector is up to, their hands are tied by the court rules.

So the lesson here is to respond to every request for admission within 30 days. You only have to admit the statement if you know for a fact that it’s true. For example, if the statement asks you to admit having a credit card with a specific 16-digit account number, unless you know for sure that is your account number, you can probably deny the request. Of course, if you have copies of your billing statements with that account number on them, you'll probably have to admit that request.

 

Stop foreclosure now

Bankruptcy is the only way to guarantee a foreclosure is stopped immediately. All the other ways of stopping foreclosure (asking for a modification, filing a postponement with the county, etc.) don’t stop foreclosure immediately either because they take time or they rely on the lender to take action. Bankruptcy is a powerful tool because it puts things into your hands and allows you to act right away.

How to stop foreclosure immediately

Filing a Chapter 7 or a Chapter 13 bankruptcy stops foreclosure right away. Any foreclosure sale that is scheduled is not only immediately canceled as of the moment a bankruptcy petition is filed, but if the sale happens regardless of the bankruptcy, the lender is required to undo it right away.

When do you need to file bankruptcy to stop a foreclosure sale?

A foreclosure sale can be stopped as long as the bankruptcy was filed immediately before the sale took place. This means that if the sale was scheduled for 10 a.m. on a Friday, filing a bankruptcy case at 9:59 stops the foreclosure. Once the sale occurs, a later bankruptcy will no longer stop that foreclosure—there may still be reasons to file, but a mortgage cannot be brought back into good standing (without paying it off in full) once the sale happens.

How much lead time does my lawyer need to prepare my case?

We have filed bankruptcy the same day the borrower got in touch. The more lead time we have, the better, but we’re often your best option if you’re down to the wire.

What do I need to gather before I stop my foreclosure?

To stop an emergency foreclosure, we’ll need a couple of things. First, your pre-filing bankruptcy fee will need to be paid in full ($2,250-$4000, depending on the case) and in certified funds (cash, cashier’s check, money order). You’ll also need to file an online credit counseling class (this is mandatory before we file an emergency case). Other than that, what you’ll need varies case-by-case, and we can let you know when we talk.

What you need to know about the collection of old debts

If you're facing debt collection on an account that is more than a couple of years old, the first thing you should do is figure out how long the statute of limitations is. The statute of limitations is the amount of time set by law for a creditor to start a lawsuit against you. In Minnesota, for example, the statute of limitations for most debt collection lawsuits is six years. This means that the lawsuit only has to be started within six years. It doesn't mean that the lawsuit has to be finished within six years.

Once you know what the statute of limitations is, you need to determine when it starts to run in your case. Generally, the statute of limitations begins to run on the first day that you are in default on your account. A quick way to figure out when your account went into default is to determine the date that you made your last regular payment. Although this won't always be a precise date that the statute of limitations began to run, it's a good estimate.

When you know the applicable statute of limitations and the date it started in your case, the rest is just simple math. Using Minnesota's six-year statute of limitations as an example again, if you defaulted on your account on December 15, 2014, the creditor must start the lawsuit against you no later than December 15, 2020.

If the creditor doesn't start the collection lawsuit within the statute of limitations, it loses its ability to use the judicial process to collect the debt. This doesn't necessarily mean that the creditor can't call or write you to collect the debt. In Minnesota, a debt collector may collect a debt that is past the statute of limitations. But it can't threaten to sue you or sue you for an old debt that is past the statute of limitations. And if the debt is more than seven years old, it can't be reported to the credit bureaus.

If the debt collector brings a lawsuit on a debt that is past the statute of limitations, you have an absolute defense to the collection lawsuit. You need to raise this defense in your answer or it may be waived. Also, it's your burden to prove that the statute of limitations is up and you may need to gather some evidence first. But this is a powerful defense that, if proven, will result in the debt collector's case being thrown out.

In addition, many courts have held that a debt collector violates the FDCPA when it threatens to bring or brings a lawsuit for an old debt that is past the statute of limitations. When a debt collector violates the FDCPA, you have the right to sue them and the law provides that the collector has to pay you up to $1,000, plus any provable actual damages--such as emotional distress. Further, the debt collector has to pay your attorney fees and costs. So if everything goes your way, you could get the debt wiped out and get some money back from the debt collector.

A quick summary of the law on the collection of old debt

(1) In Minnesota, a debt collector can attempt to collect a debt past the statute of limitations through phone calls, letters, or similar methods. This rule may be different in other states.

(2) A debt collector in Minnesota cannot, however, threaten to sue you or sue you for a debt that is past the statute of limitations. This is also true in most other states.

(3) A debt collector cannot put a debt that is more than seven years old on your credit report. This is true everywhere. I would also take the position that a debt collector cannot even threaten to report a debt that is past the statute of limitations.

 

How to vacate a judgment in a collection lawsuit

What Is a Judgment?

A judgment is a court order stating you legally owe a creditor or debt collector money. Most collection judgments happen by default. This means you didn’t serve an answer or appear in time. Once entered, a judgment can:

  • Garnish your wages (often up to 25% of take-home pay)

  • Freeze or seize bank funds

  • Place liens on your home or other real estate

In Minnesota, judgments typically last 10 years and can be renewed every 10 years. Interest and fees are added to the judgment balance over time.

Why Judgments Matter

Judgments give collectors powerful tools to reach your paycheck and bank account. They also appear in public records, making it harder to borrow, refinance, or buy property. Acting fast expands your options.

Can a Judgment Be Vacated (Undone)?

Sometimes, yes. A successful motion to vacate wipes out the judgment and re-opens the case so you can defend it. In Minnesota, courts generally require four things:

  1. A legitimate defense to the lawsuit
    You don’t have to prove you’ll win—only that your defense is real. Examples: the debt buyer can’t prove it owns your account, the evidence is incomplete/unreliable, the statute of limitations expired, or the balance is inflated.

  2. A good reason you didn’t respond
    Examples: you were out of town when served, papers went to someone else in your household and never reached you, or you never received proper notice. (Simply saying “I didn’t know I had to respond” usually isn’t enough.)

  3. You acted quickly
    Courts generally expect you to file within one year of entry of judgment. If you truly didn’t know about the judgment until later, you may have more time, but the sooner you move, the better.

  4. No unfair prejudice to the creditor
    Minnesota courts have said that extra time and expense for the collector isn’t enough by itself to block vacating.

One important thing to know: vacating the judgment doesn’t make the debt go away. It just takes you back to the beginning of the case, although you will have a chance to assert any defenses you have or, possibly, negotiate a settlement from a position of more strengthy.

Improper Service: A Different Path

If you were never properly served, the judgment may be void from the start. In Minnesota, a lawsuit begins with valid service. No service → no valid lawsuit → no valid judgment.

How We Help

We represent Minnesotans facing judgments and garnishments. We offer flat-fee options in many cases (e.g., ~$1,000 settlement-only; ~$3,500 full defense) so costs are predictable.

One thing to keep in mind is cost-benefit. For example, hiring us for $3,500 to vacate of $5,000 judgment probably doesn’t make a lot of sense. For this reason, many clients choose to settle the judgment rather than vacate it.

FAQs: Vacating a Judgment in Minnesota

How long do I have to vacate a judgment in Minnesota? Generally one year from entry of judgment. If you didn’t know about the judgment until later, you may have more time—but act quickly.

What are common defenses to a debt collection lawsuit? Debt buyer can’t prove it owns the account; evidence is incomplete or unreliable; statute of limitations has run; balance is inflated. You only need to show a legitimate defense at the vacate stage.

What if I never got the lawsuit papers? If you weren’t properly served, the judgment may be void. In Minnesota, valid service is required to start a lawsuit.

Will vacating a judgment stop garnishment? Yes, if the judgment is vacated, the creditor loses the right to garnish or levy while the case proceeds, giving you a chance to defend or negotiate.

Next Steps

If you have a judgment (or a new garnishment notice), move fast. Gather your court papers, garnishment notices, and bank statements and talk with a Minnesota debt-defense lawyer.

 

In Minnesota and ready to talk to a lawyer about a judgment?
Schedule a consult with debt defense lawyer Todd Murray.

Since 2009, Todd has helped hundreds of Minnesotans get out of debt. His work has saved his clients millions of dollars (and many sleepless nights) in the process. Todd’s clients have described him as “very professional and easy to work with.” He lives in Minneapolis with his wife and four children.

How to answer interrogatories in a debt collection lawsuit

In the past, I've written about the importance of answering a debt collection lawsuit. But answering the lawsuit is only the first step. After the debt collector receives your answer, they'll usually send you written discovery. The discovery will probably have interrogatories, requests for production of documents, and requests for admission. In Minnesota, it's critical that you respond to each of these things within 30 days of receiving them.

This post focuses on how to respond to interrogatories. Interrogatories are simply just questions about the case. Debt collectors are allowed to ask about anything that is relevant to their claims or your defenses. Do your best to answer each question. If you don't understand what the interrogatory is asking, then you may answer that you object to the interrogatory as vague or ambiguous. Your answers to each interrogatory are due within 30 days. Unlike requests for admission, it's not fatal to your case if you don't answer within this time. But you should make every effort to answer within 30 days and you should never just ignore the interrogatories.

A final word of caution: there are many forms available online that seemingly can be used to answer debt collection discovery. But before you just copy and paste from the internet, make sure you understand what the form answers mean and whether they apply to the discovery requests for your case. And be careful with objections. Unless you understand what an objection means and are relatively sure it applies to the question you've been asked, it's probably best to just answer the question.

 

What is a summary judgment motion?

A summary judgment is a final decision by the court without having a trial. Debt collection lawsuits rarely go to trial and most are decided on a motion for summary judgment. The purpose of a trial is to resolve the facts that are disputed. In other words, the jury listens to all the witnesses’ testimony, reviews any exhibits, and decides whose story is more believable. When someone brings a summary judgment motion, they're arguing that all the important facts are undisputed, so there's no need for a jury to hear testimony and that the judge should just apply the law and make a decision. In debt collection cases, the creditor usually brings the summary judgment motion.

So what should you do if the debt collection lawyer brings a summary judgment motion in your case? First, you need to figure out if there are any facts that are disputed. If there are, the judge should deny the summary judgment motion and schedule the case for trial to resolve those disputed facts. If you come up with some, you'll need to put them in your response to the creditor's motion. In Minnesota, a response to a summary judgment motion must be filed with the court—and sent to the creditor's attorney—at least 14 days before the hearing. If you don't file a written response, you'll probably lose the case and the judge might not allow you to make any oral arguments at the hearing.

A summary judgment motion is probably the most difficult phase of a debt collection lawsuit for a non-lawyer to handle. You should strongly consider talking to a lawyer with experience defending debt collection lawsuits.

 

COVID-19 means a twelve-month break on mortgage payments for some borrowers

One of the most important provisions for consumers in the federal CARES act is the right to a twelve-month forbearance (a break) on mortgage payments for any borrower with a loan owned or insured by certain government entities. This can be a huge help to borrowers who are in financial difficulty right now, but also comes with some risks.

What loans qualify for the program?

The law applies to any loans owned by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, insured by HUD, the VA, or the USDA, or directly made by the USDA. According to the CFPB, nearly half of all U.S. home mortgages are owned or backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. Some borrowers can look up their loans at this link, to see if you qualify.

If your mortgage does not qualify for this program, your individual servicer may have its own forbearance program, just call to find out.

How do I get a break on my payments?

Typically you can call your servicer to request the forbearance. They have to offer it to all qualifying borrowers any obstacles, including no fees, charges or additional interest. The forbearance also may not result in any negative credit reporting. Note, the payments are not forgiven, they need to be repaid after the end of the forbearance through a few different payment options. You should ask your lender, before you take the forbearance, how missed payments will be handled.

How do I repay my mortgage payments once the forbearance is over?

This is one of the biggest unanswered questions about this program, and a potential real danger for people who participate in it. And many borrowers have not been able to get their lenders to commit to what will happen until the payments actually come due. There are a few different possible payback options:

  • Lump-sum payback at the end of the forbearance: This is the scariest option for most borrowers—that they’ll be required to pay the missed payments back in full, all at one time. This is likely to be impossible for most people.

  • Short-term mortgage modification: This option, first of all, assumes that the economy will be back to normal after 12 months, but also requires that borrowers stretch to pay the missed payments back over a few months to a couple of years. This option is likely to result in many foreclosures in the coming year.

  • Long-term mortgage modification: Allowing borrowers to spread their missed mortgage payments out over the remaining term of the mortgage will help keep more people out of foreclosure. For example, for a borrower with a $1,500 mortgage payments and 20 years remaining on their mortgage, a one-year forbearance will increase their monthly payment by $75 per month for the remainder of the loan.

  • Tacking payments onto the end of the mortgage: Another good option that will keep people out of foreclosure is to take the missed payments and add them to the end of the mortgage, extending the length of the mortgage loan up to 12 months. This options should help people get through the hard times without attaching a ticking time bomb to the end of the 12-month forbearance.

What if I need help when my mortgage forbearance is over?

There may be a couple of ways to get help if your mortgage company is asking for an unreasonable increase in your payments at the end of a forbearance. One would be to apply for a loan modification with the services. Another would be to file Chapter 13 bankruptcy, to spread the missed mortgage payments out over five years and allow you to pay it back a little at a time.

This is all new territory for everyone, so please let us know if you have any issues and we can help.

,

Bankruptcy discharge: private student loans can be wiped out in some cases

,

Many people are under the incorrect belief that student loans can’t be wiped out in bankruptcy. However, there are at least two ways to get rid of student loans in a bankruptcy case.

The first is to show the court that the loan would cause “undue hardship” and so based on that borrower’s specific situation, the loan should be wiped out. We discuss that in another article. The second is to prove that a particular loan does not meet the legal definition of “educational loan” under the Bankruptcy Code and therefore is just an ordinary loan that can be wiped out in bankruptcy.

There are two “exceptions to discharge” that may prevent student loans from being wiped out in bankruptcy.

  1. An educational loan made, insured, or guaranteed by a governmental unit, or made under any program funded in whole or in part by a governmental unit or nonprofit institution; or

  2. Any other educational loan that is a qualified education loan, as defined in section 221(d)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, incurred by a debtor who is an individual

Governmental unit or nonprofit institution

This exception covers federal and state loans. It also covers loans “made under any program funded in whole or in part by a nonprofit institution.” This sentence in the bankruptcy law caused a whole bunch of student lenders to use nonprofits just for the purpose of funding/guaranteeing their loans. In the paperwork, you may see the name of a nonprofit like The Education Resources Institute (TERI). We believe that many of these loans were not meaningfully funded by nonprofits, but instead the lender “rented” the nonprofit’s name just to avoid the loans being dischargeable in bankruptcy. This is one factor we’ll look at if we represent you in your student loan bankruptcy case.

Qualified education loan

A qualified education loan is a very complex definition that requires looking at a handful of different federal laws, but basically the loan had to be made to an eligible student (half-time or more), at an accredited school, and the loan may not have been for more than the cost of attendance at the school, and solely for educational expenses.

How to make your case

Although the two definitions above make the majority of student loans non-dischargeable in bankruptcy, we believe that a lot of loans don’t meet either definition. You can make your case either by filing an “adversary proceeding” in your bankruptcy case, or by using these arguments as a defense to a student loan collection lawsuit after you have filed bankruptcy. We are one of the only law firms in Minnesota that handles student loan discharge cases, and our prices begin at $5,000. Get in touch if you have questions.

,

Bankruptcy discharge: student loans can be wiped out if there is "undue hardship"

,

Many people are under the incorrect belief that student loans can’t be wiped out in bankruptcy. However, there are at least two ways to get rid of student loans in a bankruptcy case.

The first is to show the court that a particular loan does not meet the legal definition of “educational loan” under the Bankruptcy Code. We discuss that in another article. The second one is to show that the loan would cause “undue hardship” and so based on that borrower’s specific situation, the loan should be wiped out.

In Minnesota, courts look at three factors to figure out whether a loan causes undue hardship.

  1. The borrower’s past, present and reasonably reliable income and assets;

  2. A calculation of the borrower’s reasonable necessary living expenses for their family; and

  3. Any other relevant facts and circumstances.

This test is applied case-by-case and really depends on how well a borrower can paint the financial picture both that they can’t afford to pay their loans now, and also convince the court they will not be able to pay in the future. It’s helpful to be able to prove some kind of disability or condition that makes it harder to work or makes the stress of student loans too much to bear.

It’s much easier to wipe out private loans than federal loans using the bankruptcy process. Discharging student loans requires that you file bankruptcy first, and then file a separate case, called an adversary proceeding, against the student lender. Typical fees in a student loan discharge case are between $7,500 and $15,000, but they vary case-by-case.

We’re one of the only law firms in Minnesota who handle student loan discharge cases. Get in touch for a free consultation to figure out whether you’ll qualify.

How to deal with federal student loans

As total student loan debt in the United States approaches $1 trillion, many borrowers are going into default. On federal student loans alone, the number of people who went into default during the first three years after graduation was a staggering 13.4 percent. There are a few things borrowers can do to deal with runaway student loans.

If the federal student loan is not in default

If a federal student loan is not in default, there are numerous repayment options available, including a number of income-driven payment options. Each of these programs allow a borrower to pay a percentage of his income to his loans (sometimes as low as zero percent) and the remaining debt is forgiven after a number of years (20-25). The government has a web site that allows you to explore these options.

If the federal student loan is in default

Once default occurs, income-driven repayment plans aren't available anymore and the student lender will tack on a 25 percent collection fee to the balance. The lender can then garnish wages and seize tax returns. If a loan is in default, you have two options: rehabilitation or consolidation.

Rehabilitation

In our experience, rehab is the best option for most borrowers. To rehabilitate your federal loans, you must make nine consecutive reasonable and affordable payments. The payment amounts are determined by your disposable income and can be as low as $5 per month. To start the rehab process, contact your loan servicer and request info on rehab. The servicer is required by law to give you this information. You will likely have to submit some form of income verification.

Once you’ve made the required payments, your loan will be taken out of default status and income-based repayment options are available again. The default status will be removed from your credit report, although past late payments can still be reported.

You can begin the rehab process even if your wages are being garnished or tax refunds are being seized, though the garnishment or seizure probably won’t stop until you’ve made all the rehab payments.

It’s also important to understand that you can only rehab a defaulted loan one time. So it’s critical to transition to an income-driven repayment option once you’ve completed the rehab so you don’t default again.

Consolidation

Consolidation is the process of paying off your defaulted federal student loans with a new loan. Consolidation may be an attractive option for a person who can’t wait nine months to get out of default. Typically, this is someone who wants to go back to school right away and needs immediate access to additional federal student aid that isn’t available when loans are in default. Most, but not all, federal loans are eligible for consolidation.

Before you can consolidate your loans you must either: (1) make three consecutive fully monthly payments; or (2) agree to pay off the new consolidated loan through an income-driven repayment plan.

You can begin the consolidation process by requesting info from your servicer or apply for a consolidation loan directly through the federal government. Consolidation isn’t available if your wages are being garnished, unless you can get the garnishment order lifted.

After consolidation, past late payments and past default status will remain on your credit report.

Finally, consolidation is generally only available one time—you typically cannot consolidate a loan that has already been consolidated.

Discharging federal student loans outside bankruptcy

A federal loan can be administratively discharged by the U.S. Government for a few reasons. These include things like the borrower becomes totally disabled or the school closes while the borrower is attending. More information about these options is available on the federal student loan website.

Discharging federal student loans in bankruptcy

Contrary to popular belief, student loans can be discharged in bankruptcy, but it's not always easy. A student loan can be discharged if paying it would cause "undue hardship" to the borrower. It's not totally clear what this means, since different courts have interpreted this in different ways, but it's definitely something more than just not being able to afford to pay off loan on a borrower's current income. A borrower generally has to show that she will never be able to pay off the loan to have it wiped out in bankruptcy.

Payment plans in Chapter 13 bankruptcy

One last option for borrowers struggling to pay private loans is Chapter 13 bankruptcy. In Chapter 13, a borrower can force the lender to enter a repayment plan over a five-year period.  This can be necessary where a borrower is being sued and the lender is demanding the full amount to be paid at once "or else." The downside to this approach is that if the court-ordered payments are low enough, interest will accumulate faster than it's paid off and the borrower will owe more at the end of the five years.

How to deal with private student loans

Unlike federal student loans, borrowers have few good options for dealing with unmanageable private student loan payments. If your private loan has gone into default, here’s what you need to know.

your options for defaulted private loans

You basically have three options for dealing with a private student loan in default: (1) negotiate a settlement or payment plan with the debt collector; (2) wait to be sued and defend yourself in court; (3) try to wipe out the private loans in bankruptcy.

Negotiation

Private student loan borrowers do not have the protection of federal income-based repayment options. You’ll have to work with the debt collector and try to agree on a reasonable settlement or payment plan you can afford.

Defend yourself in court

If the debt collector won’t be reasonable about settlement, another option is to wait to be sued and defend yourself in court. There are a variety of defenses available in a private student loan lawsuit. While the best case scenario would be getting the case thrown out, in most cases pushing back in court will soften the collector’s bargaining position and get you a more reasonable settlement.

Discharge in bankruptcy

It is difficult, but not impossible, to wipe out private student loans in bankruptcy. You should consult with a bankruptcy lawyer experienced in dealing with student loan issues to see if discharge might be a viable option for you.

Your rights when dealing with private loan debt collectors

Knowledge is power and you should educate yourself on your rights when dealing with private student loan debt collectors. The Fair Debt Collection Practices Act forbids collectors from using misleading, abusive, or harassing collection tactics. You can sue a debt collector who breaks the law even if you owe the debt and there are many benefits to holding a debt collector accountable.

Common FDCPA violations in student loan collections include misleading threats about garnishment and lying to you about wiping out your student loans in bankruptcy.

How to defend a private student loan lawsuit

Procedurally, there aren’t any differences between a private student loan lawsuit and any other debt collection lawsuit. The lawsuit begins with the service of a summons and complaint. Even if the summons doesn’t have a court file number, you must still answer it within 20 days. Your answer must respond to all of the allegations in the complaint and should identify your defenses.

The defenses in a collection lawsuit, however, are somewhat different than those typically asserted in, say, a credit card collection lawsuit. Here is a list of some of the more common defenses in a private student loan lawsuit.

statute of limitations

The statute of limitations in a private student loan lawsuit in Minnesota is generally six years from the date you defaulted on the student loan. Be careful, though, because this analysis can be complex. You need to look at the default triggers in your loan agreement and think carefully about when you first went into default. Depending on your agreement, it may not have been when you first missed a payment. Next, you need to figure out whether Minnesota’s six year statute of limitations period is applicable, or whether another state’s shorter statute of limitations period applies. Then you need to calculate the time between your default and the end of the applicable time limit to determine whether the lawsuit was started in time.

If you can show that your lawsuit was beyond the statute of limitations, a Court should throw it out.

illegal interest rate

Watch out, this one is tricky too. Most states limit how high an interest rate can be charged for certain loans. But there is also a federal law, the National Bank Act, that may allow some lenders to avoid state law interest rate caps. To figure out whether the interest rate on your loan is too high involves a complicated analysis of who your lender is, where they are located, and what interest rate law applies. This is even more difficult because many student loans have variable interest rates that change over time.

If you can show that the interest rate charged was illegal, you should be able to reduce the amount owed. In some cases, you may be able to eliminate the student loan debt entirely.

discharge in bankruptcy

If you filed bankruptcy after taking out the student loans, you may be able to show that the loans were wiped out in your bankruptcy. This, too, is a complicated analysis that involves looking at who made your loan, where you went to school, what you went to school for, whether you used the student loan proceeds for anything other than education, and a bunch of other factors.

But if you can show that your loan was not the type that is automatically discharged in your bankruptcy, you might be able to get a court to throw out the lawsuit.

insufficient evidence

Many private student loans are being acquired by debt buyers. Because they didn’t originate the loan, debt buyers may not have sufficient evidence to prove that they own the debt or the amount owed.

Contract formation issues

If you never agreed to the loan and signed the paperwork, the loan contract shouldn’t be binding. We’ve seen several cases where the primary borrower forged a co-signor’s signature, so if you don’t recognize a loan, you should ask some questions before you concede owing it.

Differences between federal and private student loans

Probably the first step in figuring out your options for dealing with student loans is to determine whether your loans are federal loans or private loans. Here are the key features of each:

FEDERAL STUDENT LOANS

Federal student loans are made or guaranteed by the Department of Education. The most common federal student loan types are Stafford, Direct Loan, PLUS, and Perkins loans. Borrowers can use the National Student Loan Data System to figure out what type of federal loans they have.

Federal student loans generally have lower interest rates and the law gives borrowers many more options for dealing with them if the payments become too burdensome. However, there are very few defenses available if the government begins legal action after default.

Federal student loans are difficult, though not impossible, to wipe out in bankruptcy.

PRIVATE STUDENT LOANS

Private student loans are typically made by banks, credit unions, state agencies, or schools themselves. They may have names like “alternative” or “institutional” loans.

Private student loans typically have higher interest rates than federal loans and the borrower’s credit history will often determine the precise terms. And unlike federal loans, borrowers have very few options if they fall behind on payments. On the bright side, borrowers may have more defenses available if a private student loan lender begins legal proceedings.

Although still challenging to discharge in bankruptcy, private student loans may be a little easier to wipe out than federal loans.

How to know if your student loan is in "default"

A federal student loan is in default if you have gone more than 270 days (9 months) without making a required payment. Once a federal loan is in default, a 25% collection fee will be added to the balance and the government may seek to garnish your wages or seize your federal tax refund.

Private student loan default is governed by the loan agreement and may begin after just one missed payment. Private loan contracts also typically provide for default if the borrower: (1) breaks any promise in the loan agreement; (2) files bankruptcy; or (3) makes a false statement in the loan application.

Once a private loan is in default, the loan may be referred to a debt collector or the borrower may get sued by a collection law firm.

,

Common FDCPA violations in student loan collections

,

The total amount of federal student loan debt in the U.S. is about one trillion dollars. When a borrower falls behind on payments, the student loan collections process begins. Although federal student loan collectors have impressive collection powers, it's important for consumers to recognize that the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act still prevents a debt collector from making false or misleading statements or otherwise harassing or abusing a consumer. Here are some of the most frequent FDCPA violations in student loan collections:

Misleading threats to garnish wages

Debt collectors often mislead or lie to consumers about the imminence of a wage garnishment if the consumer doesn't pay immediately. A federal student loan collector may institute an administrative wage garnishment against a consumer who is delinquent. No judgment is required. But there are important steps that a collector must follow before starting an administrative wage garnishment. They must send the consumer a notice--at least 30 days before starting the garnishment--that advises the consumer of their right to inspect the records related to the debt, their right to a written repayment agreement, and their right to a hearing. The consumer then has 15 days to request a hearing. And a private student loan collector doesn't have the ability to do an administrative wage garnishment. They have to sue the consumer and get a court judgment first. So, a collector can't just start a wage garnishment immediately if the consumer doesn't pay and any threats to the contrary probably violate the FDCPA.

Lies about how to get a federal student loan out of default

Debt collectors often lie to or mislead consumers about the ability to get a loan out of student loan collections. A federal student loan is considered to be in "default" if the borrower goes 270 days without making a payment. Once the loan is in default, a 25% collection fee may be tacked on. But a borrower can get a federal student loan out of default by "rehabilitating" the loan. This means making nine voluntary, reasonable, and affordable monthly payments within 20 days of the due date during ten consecutive months. A borrower may also be able to get the loans out of default by consolidating into a single loan. Debt collectors often tell consumers that there's nothing they can do to get the loan out of default, or don't tell them about all of their options, which may violate the FDCPA.

Telling consumers that they can't discharge student loans in bankruptcy

Student loan collectors often tell consumers that student loans can't be discharged in bankruptcy. While this is often true, it isn't always true. A borrower may be able to get a student loan discharged if they can prove undue hardship. The burden of proving undue hardship is very difficult, but it can, and has, been done. A debt collector that tells you that student loans can never be eliminated in bankruptcy isn't telling the truth and is likely violating the FDCPA.

Illegal contacts with third parties

Under the FDCPA, a student loan collector (or any collector) can't communicate with your family members, co-workers, friends, or other third parties. Even threats to do so probably violate the FDCPA.

The bottom line

If a student loan collector chooses to give a consumer legal advice, they better get it right. Making false statements about the law or a consumer's options probably violates the FDCPA.

"As is" isn't a free pass to rip you off

We get a lot of calls from people who have been fraudulently sold cars with serious defects. When the buyer confronted the dealer about the problem and demanded her money back, the dealer insisted that the car was sold "as is," and so it's "not my problem." But the dealers don't understand the law--there are several reasons why a buyer has legal claims even when the car is sold as is. Let’s break down a few of them here:

  • The car was sold with a warranty or a service contract. Under federal law, a dealer can't disclaim "implied warranties" in a sale if it provided a warranty or a service contract.

  • The dealer lied about the vehicle’s condition. Under Minnesota law, a dealer can't sell a vehicle as-is if it makes a false statement about a serious defect.

  • A dealer can't get off the hook for specific statements it made about the car. A dealer’s verbal statements about the car, called express warranties, can never be disclaimed. This means that if the dealer said "the car has never been in an accident," or or "the check engine light is only on because the car needs a new oxygen sensor" when it actually needs a new engine, it can't squirm out of those untrue statements by hiding behind "as is."

There is a lot of nuance to these scenarios and a detailed legal analysis is required before it’s clear whether you’ll be able to defeat “as-is” in your case. But it’s important for buyers to know that just because their car was sold “as-is” doesn’t mean that they’re out of luck.

 

Sold a vehicle “as-is” and wondering if you can do anything?
Click to learn the types of cases we handle.

Can I wipe out tax debt in bankruptcy?

This post describes how to deal with tax debt in bankruptcy.  Tax debt is one of the hardest kinds of debt to shake. First of all, the IRS knows where you are. Also, they have special enforcement powers to collect their debt. They can put a lien on your house or your property without suing you. They can take money in your bank account without a judgment. They can seize tax refunds. They can take you social security. And they can also garnish your wages, often for a lot of money. But contrary to popular belief, tax debt can be wiped out in bankruptcy , especially if it's old. Here's how it works.

1. The rules: For income tax debt to be wiped out in bankruptcy, the following three rules must apply:

Rule 1: The income tax return must have been due more than three years ago. The first question we ask to figure out income tax dischargeability is whether the tax return was due more than three years before the date of bankruptcy filing. 2008 income taxes were due on April 15, 2009. Today is February 8, 2012. These taxes are not dischargeable today, but they pass this test if we wait until April 16 to file. But there's one wrinkle. If you filed for a six-month extension that year, your tax return wasn't due until October 15, 2009. So if you're looking to discharge income taxes, we can't file your bankruptcy case until October 16, 2012.

Rule 2: The income tax return must have been filed more than two years ago. This one seems easy. If the return was filed more than two years before today, this test is satisfied. In some cases, the taxpayer never actually files a return, and so the tax agency files one for them (sometimes called a "substitute return."). When that happens, the two-year clock never starts running, and until the taxpayer actually files his/her own return, this test can never be met.

Rule 3: The tax must have been assessed more than 240 days ago. This means that the tax agency's determination that you owe a debt must have been made more than 240 days ago. The "determination" can be a few different things--wither you filed your return and acknowledged you owe a balance. That's an assessment. Or the IRS changed your return to say that you owed a balance. That's an assessment too. Finally, if you were audited, and the IRS added a balance based on the results of the audit, that's an assessment too. This part of the test is the most confusing, and you might want to see a tax professional (tax accountant or attorney) to figure out the assessment date.

2. Other factors add time to the clock. If you've filed bankruptcy before, the amount of time your case was open, plus six months, are added to all the time limits above. Also, filing an Offer in Compromise with the tax agency can stop the clock.

3. Some kinds of taxes are never dischargeable. Income taxes can be discharged if they meet all the above tests. There are other kinds of debts, such as sales taxes or payroll taxes collected on behalf of an employee, that will never be dischargeable. See a tax attorney if you're facing these types of debts.

4. If a tax debt can't be discharged, you still may be able to stop collection by filing Chapter 13. Chapter 13 bankruptcy stops all collection efforts by a tax agency, and allows you to spread the tax debt over a three to five-year period. This can be a big relief when the tax agency is looking to put liens on your property or garnish your wages, sometimes up to 90 percent of your income.

How does Chapter 13 work?

How does Chapter 13 work? Clients are asking us about Chapter 13 Bankruptcy, and while it has some similarities to Chapter 7, it's also way different. Chapter 7 fits best where you can't pay your debts and don't have many valuable possessions, but Chapter 13 makes sense if you have substantially more income (you can pay a portion of what you owe over time) and/or you own property that is not covered by the bankruptcy exemptions.

Chapter 13 can stop foreclosure

We often use Chapter 13 to stop foreclosure. Chapter 13 can allow a homeowner to catch up on missed mortgage payments, pay tax debts over time, or to wipe out an underwater second mortgage.

How Chapter 13 works

We figure out your disposable income, which basically means your take-home pay minus your actual living expenses.

How much do I have to pay to creditors? Once we know your disposable income, that may be close to what your "plan payment" will be. Your plan payment is the amount of money you will pay to your creditors over a three-to-five-year period. In general, your plan payment goes to pay off your secured debt (like a car loan) in full, as well as your priority debt (overdue taxes, government penalties, etc.) A portion of your general unsecured debt (credit cards, medical bills, legal judgments) is paid out of the rest of your plan payment, but that doesn't have to be paid in full, and lots of times, can be paid at pennies on the dollar..

How do I make my plan payments? You make plan payments directly to the Bankruptcy Trustee, who tacks on an additional fee (in Minnesota, the fee is about 7 percent of your payment) and spreads each payment out to your creditors. You need to have steady enough income to stick to payments, because if you miss them your case will almost certainly be dismissed.

How much does Chapter 13 cost? The filing fee is currently $310, which is 25 bucks less than the Chapter 7 filing fee. The total attorney's fee for Chapter 13 is usually more than Chapter 7, but most times you end up paying the same or even less, since we have the ability to take some of our fees from the plan payments, meaning that it comes out of your creditors' pockets, not yours.

How do we know which chapter you should file? There are a few common scenarios where you might choose a Chapter 13 bankruptcy.