Bankruptcy discharge: private student loans can be wiped out in some cases

Many people are under the incorrect belief that student loans can’t be wiped out in bankruptcy. However, there are at least two ways to get rid of student loans in a bankruptcy case.

The first is to show the court that the loan would cause “undue hardship” and so based on that borrower’s specific situation, the loan should be wiped out. We discuss that in another article. The second is to prove that a particular loan does not meet the legal definition of “educational loan” under the Bankruptcy Code and therefore is just an ordinary loan that can be wiped out in bankruptcy.

There are two “exceptions to discharge” that may prevent student loans from being wiped out in bankruptcy.

1. An educational loan made, insured, or guaranteed by a governmental unit, or made under any program funded in whole or in part by a governmental unit or nonprofit institution; or

2. Any other educational loan that is a qualified education loan, as defined in section 221(d)(1) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, incurred by a debtor who is an individual

Governmental unit or nonprofit institution

This exception covers federal and state loans. It also covers loans “made under any program funded in whole or in part by a nonprofit institution.” This sentence in the bankruptcy law caused a whole bunch of student lenders to use nonprofits just for the purpose of funding/guaranteeing their loans. In the paperwork, you may see the name of a nonprofit like The Education Resources Institute (TERI). We believe that many of these loans were not meaningfully funded by nonprofits, but instead the lender “rented” the nonprofit’s name just to avoid the loans being dischargeable in bankruptcy. This is one factor we’ll look at if we represent you in your student loan bankruptcy case.

Qualified education loan

A qualified education loan is a very complex definition that requires looking at a handful of different federal laws, but basically the loan had to be made to an eligible student (half-time or more), at an accredited school, and the loan may not have been for more than the cost of attendance at the school, and solely for educational expenses.

How to make your case

Although the two definitions above make the majority of student loans non-dischargeable in bankruptcy, we believe that a lot of loans don’t meet either definition. You can make your case either by filing an “adversary proceeding” in your bankruptcy case, or by using these arguments as a defense to a student loan collection lawsuit after you have filed bankruptcy. We are one of the only law firms in Minnesota that handles student loan discharge cases, and our prices begin at $5,000. Get in touch if you have questions.

Bankruptcy discharge: student loans can be wiped out if there is "undue hardship"

Many people are under the incorrect belief that student loans can’t be wiped out in bankruptcy. However, there are at least two ways to get rid of student loans in a bankruptcy case.

The first is to show the court that a particular loan does not meet the legal definition of “educational loan” under the Bankruptcy Code. We discuss that in another article. The second one is to show that the loan would cause “undue hardship” and so based on that borrower’s specific situation, the loan should be wiped out.

In Minnesota, courts look at three factors to figure out whether a loan causes undue hardship.

1. The borrower’s past, present and reasonably reliable income and assets;

2. A calculation of the borrower’s reasonable necessary living expenses for their family; and

3. Any other relevant facts and circumstances.

This test is applied case-by-case and really depends on how well a borrower can paint the financial picture both that they can’t afford to pay their loans now, and also convince the court they will not be able to pay in the future. It’s helpful to be able to prove some kind of disability or condition that makes it harder to work or makes the stress of student loans too much to bear.

It’s much easier to wipe out private loans than federal loans using the bankruptcy process. Discharging student loans requires that you file bankruptcy first, and then file a separate case, called an adversary proceeding, against the student lender. Typical fees in a student loan discharge case are between $7,500 and $15,000, but they vary case-by-case.

We’re one of the only law firms in Minnesota who handle student loan discharge cases. Get in touch for a free consultation to figure out whether you’ll qualify.

Can I discharge student loan debt in bankruptcy?

This post describes how to deal with student loan debt in bankruptcy.

One of the only types of debt that can't be discharged in a bankruptcy is a student loan, and even then, there are exceptions. But student loan debt in bankruptcy can be discharged in relatively rare situations of "undue hardship"--where the debtor cannot pay back the student loan and probably won't be able to pay it anytime in the future. Under Minnesota (8th Circuit) caselaw, courts consider: (1) The filer's past, present and future reasonably reliable financial resources; (2) a calculation of the reasonable living expenses of the debtor and his/her dependents; and (3) any other relevant facts surrounding the bankruptcy case.

1. How to discharge student loan debt in bankruptcy. To attempt to discharge student loans in bankruptcy, the debtor can file an adversary proceeding, which is a lawsuit-within-a-bankruptcy, against the student loan company. Starting an adversary proceeding is no biggie--there's no court filing fee, and you just file a summons and complaint and send it to the creditor. After that it's pretty much like any other lawsuit.

2. Undue hardship is based on your ability to earn money to pay off your loans.

• - Determining undue hardship has a lot to do with your past and present earning power. The court will look at your job qualifications and earning history. If you have had a long history of low earnings, that might play in favor of discharge.

• - Your ability to earn money in the future is even more important. The court may consider your future job prospects, especially as compared to the size of your loan. If there's no foreseeable way to make a dent in the loan, this will play in favor of discharge.

• - Age may also be a factor. While a fresh-faced 22-year old has an entire life of indentured servitude ahead of him to pay his loans, a 65-year old may be considering retirement and won't have the same long-term earning potential.

• - Disability also plays into the determination. Debtors with disabilities may have less earning potential in some cases. This is evaluated along a spectrum--a permanent and total disability that renders someone completely unable to work may be an easier discharge case, while a partial disability that reduces earning power will probably not be the basis for dischargeability on its own.

3. If there's no money in your budget, there's no money to pay off student loans. The court will look at your monthly income and reasonably monthly expenses, and determine if there's any room for repayment of student loans. If your monthly budget is in the red, this will play in your favor.

The court may also look at your eligibility for various loan repayment programs, such as Income Based Repayment (both for federal loans only). If you can afford to make a reduced payment, that might be a factor against discharge. But even if you can afford a reduced payment, it's not a discharge dealbreaker where the loan will continue to accumulate interest and grow even though you're making payments.

If you're struggling with student loan payments and you think some of the above criteria may apply to you, give us a call.